What you can and can’t do with SAN replication

Published On: 2009-12-07By:

SAN replication is a very power tool which will let you get real time (or near real time) backups of your database on another location on your storage array, to another storage array at the local site, or to a remote storage array at another site.

However like all technologies there are some things which it is really good at, and some things which it can’t/shouldn’t be used for.  (Everything here is going to be SAN vendor dependent.  This includes features, modules you have to buy, terminology, and probably some other stuff I’m not thinking of.)

What it’s good for

SAN Replication is great for getting a real time (or near real time) backup of a LUN or several LUNs to another site or another array for local backup and DR.

SAN Replication is great for setting up a geographically distributed cluster (it’s required for it in fact).  This allows you to have the nodes of your cluster spread out between two (or more if you are really brave and/or crazy) different facilities.  Typically if you are doing synchronous replication between the arrays (this is at the storage level, not the SQL Server level) then 100 km is about as far as you want to put the facilities.  Otherwise the latency of waiting for the data to travel between the facilities starts to get to high.  If you are using asynchronous replication you can place the sites further apart as the data will commit to the local SAN, then be replication to the remote SAN after the fact.

Making a copy of your database for your DEV/QA systems.  If your DEV or QA systems are setup on the SAN, the fastest way to refresh those systems would be to make a clone of the production database, and attach the clone to the Dev/QA systems.  You could even script this out (depending on SAN vendor) so that it happens automatically or an the click of a button.

What it isn’t good for

Setting up a read only copy of the database.  While the clone or snapshot or mirror that you setup is possible mountable, the SQL Server won’t like working with those files.  Even if the SQL Server is able to mount the files as read only, it isn’t going to like the blocks that make up the files changing when it isn’t changing them.  It’s a sure fire way to have the database go suspect as soon as the checksums in memory and the checksums on disk don’t match.

That’s pretty much the only think I can think of that they aren’t all that good for.

That being said, depending on your SAN vendor and the options they provide you you can make a copy of the database, and make it readable.  If you take a clone of the LUN (I’m using EMC terminology here as that’s what I know best) which gives you a full copy which is contently updated.  You can then take a snapshot of that clone, make the snapshot writeable and mount the snapshot to the system which you want to read the data from.  The SQL Server can then mount the databases on this write-able LUN as a write-able database(s) (or read only depending on how you setup the instance to attach it/them).  Doing this will increase the IO on the backup LUN(s) as the written to blocks are copied to the clone, with the original blocks being copied to the snapshot so that the snapshot stays consistent.

Hopefully this give you some good ideas on some things you can do with your storage array.  The capabilities of your Storage Array may be different, so check with your Storage Admin as to what your array can handle.


Contact the Author | Contact DCAC


Globally Recognized Expertise

As Microsoft MVP’s and Partners as well as VMware experts, we are summoned by companies all over the world to fine-tune and problem-solve the most difficult architecture, infrastructure and network challenges.

And sometimes we’re asked to share what we did, at events like Microsoft’s PASS Summit 2015.

Awards & Certifications

Microsoft Partner       Insights Sccess Award    Technology Headlines Award    Golden Bridge Gold Award    CIO Review Top 20 Azure Solutions Providers    VMWare Partner
Microsoft Certified Master    Microsoft MVP
Share via